Consistency of T2WI-FS/ASL fusion images in delineating the volume of nasopharyngeal carcinoma

Tumor extent assessment of nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) is critical for delineating the radiotherapeutic target region. We aimed to investigate the use of the fusion images of fat suppressed T2WI (T2WI-FS) with arterial spin labeling (ASL) in measuring the volume of NPC. Two observers measured the volume of 21 untreated NPC using T2WI-FS, T2WI-FS/ASL (with PLD = 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 s) fusion images and enhanced T1WI separately. Correlation and consistency were used to compare 1) measurements using T2WI-FS/ASL and T2WI-FS alone, taking enhanced T1WI images as a benchmark; 2) measurements between observers. Significant correlations existed between different series (r: 0.896~0.973). Measurements from the two observers using T2WI-FS/ASL had relatively higher intra-class correlation (ICC) (0.980~0.997) and lower within-subject coefficients of variation (wsCV) (14.76%~22.96%) when compared to using T2WI-FS alone (ICC: 0.978, 0.951, wsCV: 21.61%, 24.21%), while the T2WI-FS/ASL 1.0 s exhibited the best performance. Remarkably high ICC value (0.981~0.996) and relatively low wsCV (9.95%~17.91%) were obtained for the two observers using same series. Compared to those obtained using T2WI-FS alone, measurements made using T2WI-FS/ASL were more consistent with those made using enhanced T1WI. The T2WI-FS/ASL fusion images has the potential to be an alternative to enhanced T1WI, when contrast administration can not be performed.